Reviews of Sal's Authentic NY Pizza Mount Maunganui. (Restaurant) in Mount Maunganui (Bay of Plenty).

Name: Sal's Authentic NY Pizza Mount Maunganui
Address: 217 Maunganui Road, Mount Maunganui 3116, New Zealand, Mount Maunganui, Bay of Plenty
Telephone: +6475747257
Price range: €€
Rating: 4.4

Sal's Authentic NY Pizza Mount Maunganui

316 Reviews

182 Comments

Sal's Authentic NY Pizza Mount Maunganui

Restaurant

Pizza restaurant

217 Maunganui Road, Mount Maunganui 3116, New Zealand

View all the reviews

Description Map Open Hours Reviews Contact Photos

Description

Information of Sal's Authentic NY Pizza Mount Maunganui, Restaurant in Mount Maunganui (Bay of Plenty)

Here you can see the location, open hours, popular times, contact, photos and real reviews done by the users.

This place has good reviews, this means that they treat their customers well and you’ll feel great with their services, recommended 100%!

Map

Open hours of Sal's Authentic NY Pizza Mount Maunganui

Sunday

11:30am–10pm

Monday

11:30am–9pm

Tuesday

11:30am–9pm

Wednesday

11:30am–9pm

Thursday

11:30am–9pm

Friday

11:30am–9:30pm

Saturday

11:30am–10pm

Popular times

Sunday

11
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20

Monday

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20

Tuesday

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20

Wednesday

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20

Thursday

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21

Friday

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21

Saturday

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20

Reviews of Sal's Authentic NY Pizza Mount Maunganui

The good: Pizza was ok, garlic knots excellent. 35 minute wait which was fine as we were warned in advance. The bad: Ran out of beer on tap, tables are too small, the restaurant was hot, no blinds on window so blinded by light, the tables were nasty & grubby. I expect better for the price. Ironically this reproduces an authentic N.Y. experience. Tasty but oily pizza served in cheap and grotty surroundings, however N.Y. pizza is a relatively inexpensive fast food.

Nice NY style pizza, a great cheesecake, and a friendly staff! Mamma Mia

Love SAL'S pizza, no matter which Sal's you go to, it's all consistently yummy. Tried Wellington & Tauranga and the flavor is the same. I enjoy the knots dipped in Sal's special dipping sauce.

+ Best "fast food" pizza I ever had + Very fresh tasting tomato sauce + Nice thin dough with decent flavor - Waits can be long - Not the most cozy place to eat, can be noisy - I wonder what the carbon footprint of these pizzas is like since the ingredients come from the other side of the world

Best NY style pizza in town; if you love NY style pizza, you will love this. They get it right. You will think you are in New York.

The pizza here is great, as is the service. This is the most New York like pizza I've had outside of New York! Note: Be sure to try the garlic knots! They are wonderfully chewy and garlicky, the best we've ever had (even better than other Sal's locations in Auckland)!

It's my wife's favorite pizza place. Mozzarella sticks, yum! Pizzas are great. Buffalo wings are my favorite. Thank you!

We love Sal's pizzas! Their soft pizza bases makes for scrumptious pizzas. Unfortunately, as a vegan, there is only one option available to me and it's rather boring. Would love it if you could incorporate more interesting toppings and flavours into your pizzas and also add vegan cheese for your vegan option.

Great value for money, nice NY style fresh pizza and Ben&Jerry ice cream 1👍👍👍

Awesome as always sals never disappoints and is a hit with the kids

Awesome pizza. Best in the Mount. Shame they don't have a store at The Crossing.

The pizza was very very tasty and very New Yorkesque. They were very quick and made for a tasty pizza.

I wouldn't normally choose to eat pizza but majority ruled. The pizzas were very good. I didn't notice any dessert options. It's a clean establishment. They don't serve hot drinks.

Best pizza ever in my life. Couldnt wait 3-4 mins btw.

Really enjoyed the pizza! Nice toppings and a really decent size. Mozzarella sticks are fantastic, can order everything online for pickup or delivery.

wait time was actually not too bad. pizzas here are amazing. the staff that served us was friendly

Museum is still under inspection and renovation. Surrounding garden is beautifully maintained

This Sal's is one of the best I've ever been to - the pizza was insanely fresh and the garlic knots are to die for! The girl at the front counter was incredibly kind and really made our night with her wonderful service. :)

Decent american style pizza. One large pizza is plenty enough for 3 adults and 3 children.

Best Pizzas ever! I highly recommend Sal's, its my tradition to call in whenever I'm over at the Mount, even though the wait is sometimes long. They make Pizzas better than any I tried from the vendors in New York City. I highly recommend the Buffalo, if u don't mind spiciness. Alternatively the pepperoni is always good! 11/10

Awesome pizza, great service.

Decent little pizza joint in downtown Mount Maunganui. They were happy took to order as the slice I wanted wasn't there. Pizza was great and the vibe inside the place was good too. Parking can be difficult if it's busy in town, otherwise not an issue.

Great pizza as always from Sal's. Good crust. Clean flavours. Always authentic ingredients. Quick, friendly service and general good vibes here. Would recommend.

As always Sal's always delivers the best pizza. Our pizza was so delicious, usually I can't finish one but ended up eating the whole thing. Awesome n quick service too

Great pizza as always, however had takeaway and they forgot to give us the marinara. The shared toilet needs some bleach cleaning for sanitation and odor. One of the workers had pretty good wifi as he was on his mobile the whole time we were there. We will be back for the yummy pizza.

Food was amazing as always. A perfect place for lunch or dinner. Staff were really friendly. Only downsides were that there were a few mistakes with our order.

Great place for good pizza! A whole pie fed 4 adults. We also had the original buffalo wings which were yummy and not too hot! Mozzarella sticks were good too! We'll be back for sure!

I'm used to go to Sals Mt Maunganui at form time to time but I gotta say I went 2 days ago at lunchtime and I got really surprised of how the quality has improved. Presentation and flavour!!

Pizza was lovely as always but it took so long to come out and the place was empty, the women with glasses was awesome but the guy at the back seemed like he didn't know what to do or and he wasn't exactly trying , might wanna either find someone to help the poor girl or give her a pay raise.

Best pizza in town. I’ve been to NY a few times and eaten a lot of their pizza. This stuff is authentic and delicious. We’ve been here at least 6 times already. On the pricy side but you get what you pay for

A very busy outlet, first time for me, great pizza and the garlic buns we had, I would go again, I think it was value for the money, not a long wait time, fresh pizzas, tasty and hot

Good pizzas, friendly staff. If anything, the only thing a little bad is the time it takes to get the pizza. From ordering to eating about 20mins. Though, in decent company and with some of those delicious twists, time flies by. 😊

Decent "NYC" thin crust style pizza. Not much better than Sbarro's though. Doesn't hold a candle to some other pies I have had in both NYC and New Haven.

Pizza was yum! However, we paid $45 for 1pizza, 1/2 and 1/2. Before it came out my partner asked for parmesan and we were told they had none. One half came out attached to our friends pizza, it had hardly any cheese on it, so I took it to the staff to tell them that we had paid for extra. They went through a whole rigmarole of explaining why they decided to just put it on one half and still charged us $45 🤔 but they could give us parmesan to put on our pizza. Parmesan that a few mins ago didn't exist. Pizza would have had a great review if it wasn't for the annoying experience we had.

Very good selection to choose from, great flavor and size of pizza. Value on all selections, team very good. Great flavor.

Great that Sals has come to the Bay, enjoy their pizza, such a nice place to sit and have lunch or dinner, or get some take aways. Limited seating and have been occasions when have been unable to get a seat. Staff have always been nice and friendly, will come back again.

The more Sal's there are around, the better. Have had to travel for work a lot lately so the fact that there seems to be a Sal's where I need it has been fantastic! Good to see this location living up to the great standards that Sal's represents. I'll be back that way soon and I'll definitely be back for more Sal's! 😊

Some of the best authentic pizza in the area. Huge portions, great value, and clean restaurant. Doesn't seat many, but usually a place to sit and eat.

Best pizza in New Zealand. Very authentic. I felt like I was back home. You can buy pizza by the slice as well. How come no other place does this?

Great food. Comfortable seating.

Pizza and ingredients are clearly high quality. I just simply don’t like the taste of anything they have there sadly. Would recommend to try it guess I just don’t like ny style pizza

Good pizza, served a large group of 11 relatively quick, small store, but great for grabbing a slice or some garlic knots. Pepperoni is great

Our Pizza Pie was delicious, even though we were the only two there! Took about 20mins, but the wait was worth it.

Delicious Pizza and awesome customer service! Would definitely recommend! :)

Amazing food, I recommend the pepperoni wheels.

Location is okay, 70's Americans caffè style. Slim dough pizza, nice taste, but too expensive beer - ridiculous!

Skeptical being from the NY metropolitan area, but very pleasantly surprised - this is LEGIT NY pizza for real. Got a plain and pepperoni slice, both very very good.

Pizza is great the prep time is quick but it’s disappointing that they don’t deliver to all of Tauranga but the pizza is good enough to where I don’t mind

Awesome pizza great customer service, Thau is also amazing :)

Great service, keep it up.

Nuthin' like being able to get a large slice late at nite. Authentic NY slice with parmesan and pepper flakes sprinkled on top. If ya go in close to closing they sometimes add a couple of garlic knots for free.

My best pizza place in Tauranga. Real american style pizza and great buffalo wings. Wish they open up more branches in other places.

The girls here look after ya :) 🚲📦

Great pizza, but disappointing that Sal wasn't there to serve me personally.

Not my cup of tea really... way too oily. Garlic bread knots were dance and doughy. Wouldn't go again

Can get very busy.

Tasty pizza that's HUGE!! Luckily you can buy it by the slice. I ordered half a pizza and it was enough for 2 peeps (or dinner and lunch the next day).

Awesome Pizza 🍕 anyone that visits The Mount needs to pop in for a slice, we really recommend it as the best pizza in this area.

The pizzas we ordered were brilliant as well as the friendly customer service from the staff.

Have been to Sals in the mount a few times now and always great food and friendly staff.

Great food and fast service.

Good to have a place at the mount where you can order by the slice! Very similar if not better than New York pizza.

Great pizzas, I would highly recommend the Brooklyn pizza. The hot wings are also very good

The closest thing I've ever had to legit New York Style pizza in New Zealand - the pepperoni and the margarita was especially delicious.

Very impressed with the pizza, tasted succulent. Staff were friendly & deserve a decent promotion

New York style pizza 🍕 if you like authentic NY pizza this is your place

Great pizza. Mozzarella sticks are awesome.

Best pizza and customer service ever! Thanks Thauane!

Great place and great food. Looking forward to going back.

Good vibe, clean restaurant, piping hot and delicious pizza. And a bonus, staff are friendly and excellent.

Fantastic Pepperoni Pizza (ask for added parmesan), Garlic Knots & mozzarella sticks. But quite pricey.

Great pizza and great service. Employee even let me charge my phone there 😊

Great authentic style pizza place, well recommended.

The staff were very friendly and the pizza very tasty! 😋😋

Pizza is pretty good! Living the new flavors. It's cheap too.

First time at Sals enjoyed Pizza.and friendly service

They never have pepperoni wheels like in Auckland they always have on the shelf, any store. That's disappointing.

On busy periods, expect a wait. We'll worth it. Remember anything with hot tomatos, can give you a burnt mouth

Huge pizza, enjoyed!

First time in sal's I am in love with the strawberry cheesecake ice-cream in a cardboard tub very cool 😍

Good to enjoy a Authentic Pizza. We travel from Rotorua.

Biggest pizza I've ever had and I've had a few. Highly recommend

Great pizza, a little pricey.

Great pizza!

Good pizza up to Sam's standards. Shame they close at 21:00.

Pizzas were ok. Couldn't justify price for taste.

Love it. Has become a fav of mine. NEW YORK PEPPEEONI❤❤❤❤❤❤

Didn't go there

Food was delicious. Music was way too loud

One of the best pizza store in TGA

Great NY style pizza!

Great pizza and value for you buck

I love sals. They kinda burnt the base a bit but in fairness they did offer to re do it.

Hands down best pizzas around, keep doing what you are doing!

Great pizza and get my fix of mozzarella sticks

Great pizza, good for cheap lunch.

Great pizza and extra good service too

Amazing authentic northern American pizza as per usual

Love sals pizza my fav!

Best pizza in the land. Pepperoni is the bees nees

Massive 18 inch pizzas, yummy too.

Love love love the buffalo wings and pepperoni wheels yum

Great service awesome slices for the prices👌😀

Order took 45 mins to come out when said would only take 25 :(

Two words - Delicious & salty

Best Pizza Money Can Buy. 🍕

Great pizza

Great pizza good cold as well

Been waiting for a long time for this place to open here and it has not disappointed!

Good pizza

Great pizza reasonable priced

Great pizza to eat down beach

Perfectly cooked American pizza.

Great pizza and ambiance

Best pizza joint around the mount

Pretty legit sausage and onion pie!

Delicious! Plenty of parking at the back :)

Nice pizza.... would go back

Great pizzas love em

Cooked well, not too greasy

Yum thanks

Awesome food great atmosphere

Fun international restaurant, enjoyed by all the family

Very good Sals pizza

Delicious pizza and buffalo wings

Clean tasty and nice staff ;)

Nice place delicious pizzas

Yummy yummy, excellent food, excellent service

I love sals x

Sals pizza is yummy

Love it reminds me of home!

Huge pizzas

Always delicious

Excellent food and service

delicious NY style pizza

The Pizza was do good

The classic pepperoni was awesone.

Amazing pizza

10/10

Lovely 👌

Great pizza!

Brilliant pizza

They sell beer

Big slices of pizza.

Mean Pepperoni!

Beautiful pizza

Awesome

Yum

Great food.

Excellent

Great pizza

Authentic pepperoni!!

Good pizza

Friendly staff

Great pizza

Fine

Nice pizza

PIZZA

Fat asf pizzas

Awesome food

Amazingly amazing

Mediocre pizza

😋 Delicious.

(Translated) yummyyyy (Original) yummyyyy

(Translated) Fast food pizza, fast service, pizza at the correct price on the spot or to take away. (Original) Fast-foods pizza, service rapide, pizza à prix correct sur place ou à emporter.

(Translated) The pizza is extra large (Original) La pizza es extra large

(Translated) Great service and reception, warm atmosphere and helpful staff. (Original) Ótimo atendimento e recepção, ambiente aconchegante e funcionários atenciosos.